Protecting Your Identity: A Guide to Avoiding Tax Season Scams
Tax season is often the busiest time of year for you, whether you are managing a small business or just trying to get your personal filings in order. Unfortunately, it is also the peak season for criminals. As you work to meet deadlines, fraudsters are ramping up their efforts to trick you into revealing sensitive personal data. These identity thieves use your information to file fraudulent tax returns and pocket your refund, creating a mess that can take years to untangle.
We talk about identity theft frequently because we see the aftermath firsthand. Having your identity stolen is an absolute financial nightmare. It is a relentless process to correct, and identity thieves are incredibly clever. They are constantly evolving their schemes, waiting for you to slip up just once. Our goal is to ensure that doesn't happen to you.
The Importance of Awareness
Identity thieves and scammers are masters of imitation. They frequently mimic the IRS name, official logos, and even the layout of the agency’s website to make their communications look legitimate. Sometimes, they might even pose as officials from the U.S. Department of the Treasury or other federal agencies to add a layer of false authority to their claims.
In a typical identity theft scam, the fraudster poses as a trusted institution—a government body, a bank, or a business—to trick you into sharing passwords, credit card numbers, or your Social Security number. Once they have this data, they can drain your bank accounts, run up charges on your credit cards, apply for new loans in your name, or file a fake tax return to steal your refund. These scams are often initiated through letters, faxes, emails, phone calls, or text messages.
Protecting Seniors and Retirement Savings
Scammers frequently target individuals over age 65 or those nearing retirement. They exploit the trust of seniors to gain access to financial information or direct payments. Often, if a senior falls for one scam, the criminal will continue to press for more money. The consequences are more than just the immediate loss of cash.
If you are scammed out of tax-deferred retirement funds, the IRS may treat those lost funds as a taxable distribution. This means you could be hit with ordinary income tax and, if you are under age 59½, early withdrawal penalties. While it is possible to claim a theft loss deduction if the scam was profit-motivated and recovery is unlikely, the process is incredibly complex. We encourage you to talk with your elderly family members about suspicious messages. Regular conversations about new tactics can help them stay informed and protect their hard-earned savings.
How to Spot a Modern Tax Scam
Phishing emails and "smishing" (SMS phishing) texts share common traits. They almost always create a false sense of urgency. They might claim you are in legal trouble, that you’ve won an unexpected prize, or that there is a critical problem with your account that needs immediate attention. Be wary of any unsolicited communication requesting payment or personal info.
If an offer seems too good to be true, it likely is. Always verify suspicious messages by contacting the agency or company through their official, verified channels. Here are specific red flags to watch for in an email:
- Requests for excessive data: Emails asking for your SSN, bank details, or security answers like your mother’s maiden name.
- Enticing bait: Promises of a larger-than-expected refund or offers to pay you for participating in an IRS survey.
- Threatening language: Claims that you will be arrested, fined, or have your accounts blocked if you do not respond immediately.
- Technical errors: Misspelling the name of the Internal Revenue Service or using odd phrasing. Many scams originate overseas where English is not the primary language.
- Suspicious links: Long, garbled URLs or addresses that do not begin with the official "www.irs.gov" domain. Pro tip: hover your mouse over a link to see the actual destination before clicking.
Common Phishing and Smishing Tactics
Scammers use email to install malware on your computer or lead you to fake websites that steal your credentials. Watch out for these common email themes:
- Phony Tax Refunds: Claims that you qualify for a refund you didn't know about.
- Legal Threats: Messages threatening immediate arrest for tax fraud.
- Underreported Income: Fake notices about income discrepancies that include a malicious attachment labeled as a "tax statement."
- Account Updates: Emails with links like "IRSgov" (missing the dot) asking you to update your IP PIN or online account.
- Third-Party Help: Scammers offering to set up your IRS Online Account for you to gain access to your data.
Smishing texts are equally dangerous and often include alarming language like "Your account has been put on hold" or "Unusual Activity Report." They may also include a callback number that connects you directly to a scammer who is trained to sound like a professional agent.
Proactive Steps for Your Protection
You can take control of your security with a few simple rules. First, never click links or open attachments in unsolicited tax-related messages. Remember, the IRS will never demand immediate payment over the phone or via a specific method like a gift card or wire transfer. They will not threaten you with deportation or arrest.
If you receive a suspicious message, report it. Forward phishing emails to phishing@irs.gov. For text messages, forward the details to the same address with "Text" in the subject line. One of the best defenses you have is the Identity Protection PIN (IP PIN). This is a unique six-digit number assigned by the IRS that prevents anyone else from filing a tax return using your Social Security number. It acts as a digital lock; if a return is filed without the correct PIN, the IRS rejects it automatically.
If you have been a victim of identity theft in the past, you are likely already enrolled in this program. However, any taxpayer can voluntarily opt-in through the IRS website to add this extra layer of security. A new PIN is generated every year to keep your data safe.
The Danger of Social Media Misinformation
Be careful with the tax advice you see on social media. Many influencers lack formal tax training and may encourage you to falsify information to maximize a refund. They might claim the IRS is "hiding" certain credits from you. Following this advice can lead to audits, heavy penalties, and even criminal charges. Furthermore, these viral posts are often used as traps by scammers to identify targets who are looking for tax help. Always seek guidance from a qualified professional rather than a social media trend.
A Steady Approach to Security
The IRS typically communicates through the U.S. Postal Service. They will not reach out via social media, text, or email to ask for your sensitive financial details. If you receive a letter and are unsure if it is real, or if the pressure of tax season is making you feel vulnerable to these threats, we are here to help. If this sounds familiar, we can walk you through it step by step to ensure your information stays exactly where it belongs—safe and secure.
If you have questions or need assistance with any of the issues discussed in this article, please contact our office.
Specific Threats to Business Owners and HR Professionals
While individual taxpayers are the primary target for many scammers, business owners and human resources professionals face highly specialized threats that can compromise the data of an entire workforce. One of the most dangerous tactics is known as the Business Email Compromise, specifically targeting payroll and sensitive wage data. In this scenario, a fraudster sends an email that appears to come from a high-ranking executive within the company, such as the CEO or CFO. The email typically uses a tone of extreme urgency, requesting a digital copy of all employee wage forms for an immediate administrative review or a supposed audit. Because the request looks like it comes from the top, employees in payroll or HR may feel pressured to comply quickly without verifying the source. If they do, the scammer instantly gains access to the names, addresses, and Social Security numbers of every person in the company, allowing them to file hundreds of fraudulent tax returns in a single afternoon.
Another recent and pervasive threat targets small business owners regarding the Employee Retention Credit. You may have seen advertisements or received unsolicited calls from companies promising to help you claim large sums of money through this program. While the credit itself is legitimate, many of these third-party promoters are actually operating scams. They often charge massive upfront fees and claim that every business is eligible, regardless of the actual legal requirements. They may encourage you to take aggressive positions on your tax filings that the government will later reject. This leaves the business owner responsible for paying back the credit, along with significant penalties and interest. If someone tells you that you qualify for a complex credit without first looking at your specific financial records and payroll history, you should treat it as a major red flag.
The Psychological Tactics of Fraudsters
Scammers do not just rely on technology; they use sophisticated psychological pressure to trick you into making mistakes. They understand that under stress, the human brain often bypasses logical thinking and defaults to emotional reactions. The most common trigger they use is authority. By using official-looking logos and referencing federal laws, they leverage the natural respect or fear many people have for government institutions. This creates a state of high anxiety, making the victim more likely to follow instructions without questioning them. This is why many scam calls start with the threat of immediate legal action or a visit from local law enforcement. It is designed to shut down your critical thinking and force you into a state of compliance.
They also utilize the concept of scarcity and immediate deadlines. By telling you that you only have a few hours to resolve a problem or that your bank account will be frozen by the end of the day, they deny you the time needed to consult with your accountant or a trusted friend. Another common tactic is the promise of an unexpected windfall. By claiming you have an unclaimed refund waiting for you, they tap into the desire for financial gain, leading you to share information in hopes of receiving the money. Recognizing these psychological triggers is one of the most effective ways to defend yourself. When you feel a sudden spike of panic or a sense that something is too good to be true, that is your signal to stop, take a breath, and verify the information through a separate, trusted channel.
What to Do if Your Personal Information is Compromised
If you suspect that your sensitive information has been stolen or if you have accidentally clicked on a suspicious link, you must act quickly to mitigate the damage. The first step is to document everything. Save copies of the emails or texts and note the date and time of any phone calls. You should then contact the major credit bureaus to place a fraud alert or a full credit freeze on your accounts. This simple step prevents identity thieves from opening new credit cards or taking out loans in your name. A credit freeze is a powerful tool that is free to implement and can be managed easily through the official systems of the credit reporting agencies. We recommend taking this step even if you have not been a direct victim, as it acts as a permanent shield for your credit profile.
Next, you should report the incident to the appropriate authorities. Filing a formal identity theft affidavit is a crucial step for taxpayers. This alert ensures that the tax authorities are aware of the risk to your account and can take extra precautions when processing your returns. You should also update all of your passwords, especially for your email and financial accounts. Using a password manager and enabling multi-factor authentication can provide a massive boost to your security. These tools ensure that even if a hacker gets your password, they still cannot access your account without a physical code from your mobile device. We can assist you in reviewing your past filings and setting up a plan to monitor your tax account for any unauthorized activity.
Avoiding the Ghost Preparer Trap
As you look for help with your taxes, be wary of what the industry calls ghost preparers. These are individuals who get paid to prepare your taxes but refuse to sign the return or provide a professional identification number. By law, anyone who is paid to prepare federal tax returns must have a valid Preparer Tax Identification Number and must sign the return they prepare for you. Ghost preparers often promise larger refunds than anyone else or base their fees on a percentage of the total refund amount. They might print your return and tell you to sign it and mail it yourself, or for digital filings, they may refuse to put their own credentials on the form.
Working with these individuals is extremely risky. They often use shady techniques to inflate your refund, which can lead to audits and heavy penalties that you—not the preparer—will be responsible for paying. In some cases, they may even direct the refund to be deposited into their own bank accounts instead of yours. A legitimate tax professional will always be transparent about their fees, will sign the returns they prepare, and will be available to answer questions long after tax season has ended. Protecting your financial well-being starts with choosing a partner you can trust. If you have concerns about a message you have received or the legitimacy of a tax offer, we are here to provide the steady, expert guidance you need to stay safe.
Want tax & accounting tips and insights?
Sign up for our newsletter.